Read the W-2 vs. 1099 comparison chart
Calculate first to see employee wages and contractor revenue side by side. Compare cash separately from the employee benefits value you enter. Federal and state income taxes are excluded; this is not a take-home-pay or complete tax-return comparison. Supported tax year for the payroll-tax assumptions: 2026.
Which comparison answers your question?
For the difference between employee and contractor income records, read pay stub vs. 1099. For a pay-period statement versus an annual wage form, read pay stub vs. W-2. For the document versus the wage payment, use pay stub vs. paycheck.
Worker status follows the facts of the relationship. See the IRS employee and independent-contractor guidance. A favorable result does not let you choose a classification.
How it works
Each scenario stands alone: the contractor calculation does not assume simultaneous W-2 earnings. Benefits are an entered economic value, not spendable cash. Income taxes are excluded. Worker classification follows applicable law and circumstances; it is not a tax preference you can freely choose.
Example
For $60,000 W-2 wages, $8,000 in entered benefits value, $75,000 contractor revenue and $5,000 expenses, modeled W-2 employee payroll taxes are $4,590 and contractor SE taxes are $9,890.69. W-2 cash after payroll taxes is $55,410; adding benefits gives $63,410 of comparison value. Contractor cash after expenses and SE taxes is $60,109.31, or $3,300.69 lower than that W-2 comparison value. Federal and state income taxes are excluded; benefits are not cash.
Questions about this tool
Can this decide whether I should be a contractor?
No. It compares entered financial scenarios only. Worker classification follows applicable law and the working relationship, not whichever calculation is preferable.
Are these results independently verified?
No. Results and documents use the information you enter. Review the inputs and keep the underlying records.
Does a negative comparison result mean the contractor has less cash?
Not necessarily. The main result compares contractor cash with W-2 cash plus the benefits value you entered. In the default example contractor cash is higher than W-2 cash alone, but lower than W-2 cash plus $8,000 of benefits. Read the separate cash and benefits rows.
Is the employee benefits input deducted from W-2 pay?
No. It is an economic value added to the employee comparison, not an employee paycheck deduction. This tool does not fully model employee benefit contributions or a complete income-tax return.
Methodology sources
Tax year 2026. Sources reviewed September 19, 2026.