Skip to main content
PayStubProGenerate Now
Menu

Line-item examples

Traditional vs. Roth 401(k) on a Pay Stub

Reviewed November 21, 2026 · Examples use fictional people and figures

Quick answer

A traditional 401(k) contribution is subtracted before federal income tax is calculated; a Roth 401(k) contribution is taken after. Both are still subject to Social Security and Medicare. On a $2,500 paycheck with a 6% ($150) contribution, the traditional choice lowers federal withholding by $18, so take-home pay is $18 higher than with Roth.

Same contribution, two treatments

Traditional vs. Roth 401(k): one $2,500 biweekly paycheck with a $150 contribution
LineTraditional 401(k)Roth 401(k)
Gross pay$2,500.00$2,500.00
401(k) contribution (6%)−$150.00−$150.00
Federal income tax wages$2,350.00$2,500.00
Federal income tax−$198.15−$216.15
Social Security (6.2% of $2,500)−$155.00−$155.00
Medicare (1.45% of $2,500)−$36.25−$36.25
Net pay$1,960.60$1,942.60
Fictional employee: single, 2026 W-4 with no other entries, no other deductions, no state income tax.

The $18.00 difference is the $150 contribution × the 12% bracket that applies to this paycheck’s annualized wages. A Roth contribution costs more now; qualified Roth withdrawals later are generally tax-free, while traditional withdrawals are taxed. Which is better depends on your situation and isn’t something a pay stub can decide.

How it appears on the pay stub and W-2

  • Pay stubs often label these lines “401K” or “401K PRE” for traditional and “ROTH” or “401K ROTH” for Roth.
  • Year-end W-2: traditional deferrals reduce Box 1 wages and appear in Box 12 with code D; Roth deferrals stay in Box 1 and appear in Box 12 with code AA. Box 3 and Box 5 include both.
  • An employer match is not a paycheck deduction. It may appear as an informational line, but it does not reduce net pay.

See the W-2 form explained for every box and code.

2026 contribution limits

2026 employee 401(k) contribution limits (traditional and Roth combined)
Limit2026 amount
Elective deferrals, under age 50$24,500
Catch-up contributions, age 50 and older$8,000 (total $32,500)
Higher catch-up, ages 60–63$11,250 instead of $8,000
Limits apply to traditional and Roth deferrals combined. Source: IRS, November 2025 announcement.

How federal withholding was calculated

  1. Traditional: $2,350 × 26 = $61,100; minus $8,600 = $52,500; $1,240 + 12% × ($52,500 − $19,900) = $5,152; ÷ 26 = $198.15.
  2. Roth: $2,500 × 26 = $65,000; minus $8,600 = $56,400; $1,240 + 12% × ($56,400 − $19,900) = $5,620; ÷ 26 = $216.15.

Common mistakes

  • Subtracting a traditional 401(k) before calculating Social Security and Medicare.
  • Treating a Roth contribution as pre-tax for federal income tax.
  • Counting the employer match as a deduction from net pay.

How these figures were calculated

Publication 15-T (2026) Worksheet 1A, single, standard schedule, 26 periods; FICA on gross pay because elective deferrals remain FICA wages. Limits from the IRS 2026 cost-of-living announcement. Verified with the PayStubPro paycheck calculator (traditional case).

Sources

General information for legitimate payroll records, not tax or legal advice. PayStubPro prepares documents from the figures you enter; it does not verify income or employment.