Skip to main content
PayStubProGenerate Now
Menu

Line-item examples

HSA vs. FSA Deductions on a Pay Stub

Reviewed November 21, 2026 · Examples use fictional people and figures

Quick answer

HSA and health FSA contributions made through payroll under a cafeteria plan are both pre-tax for federal income tax, Social Security and Medicare. The differences are in the account: an HSA requires a high-deductible health plan, belongs to you and rolls over; a health FSA is employer-owned and largely use-it-or-lose-it, with an optional carryover of up to $680 into 2027.

HSA and health FSA compared

HSA vs. health FSA payroll deductions, 2026
FeatureHSAHealth FSA
EligibilityMust be covered by a high-deductible health plan (2026 minimum deductible $1,700 self-only, $3,400 family)Offered by the employer; no HDHP needed
2026 contribution limit$4,400 self-only; $8,750 family (includes employer contributions)$3,400 in employee salary reductions
Unused moneyStays in the account and rolls overForfeited unless the plan allows a carryover (up to $680) or a grace period
Who owns itThe employee; it stays with you if you change jobsThe employer’s plan
Taxes when contributed through payrollExcluded from federal income tax, Social Security and MedicareExcluded from federal income tax, Social Security and Medicare
W-2 reportingBox 12 code W (employee and employer contributions)Generally not reported

Worked example: both deductions on one paycheck

Sam (fictional) earns $3,000 every two weeks and elects $150 per paycheck to an HSA and $100 to a limited-purpose health FSA, both through the employer’s cafeteria plan. Over 26 paychecks that is $3,900 to the HSA (under the $4,400 self-only limit) and $2,600 to the FSA (under $3,400).

A $3,000 biweekly paycheck with and without $250 of HSA and FSA deductions
LineNo HSA or FSAWith $150 HSA + $100 FSA
Gross pay$3,000.00$3,000.00
HSA + FSA (pre-tax)—−$250.00
Taxable wages$3,000.00$2,750.00
Federal income tax−$320.38−$265.38
Social Security (6.2%)−$186.00−$170.50
Medicare (1.45%)−$43.50−$39.88
Net pay$2,450.12$2,274.24
Single, 2026 W-4 with no other entries, no state income tax. The $250 set aside lowers take-home pay by $175.88.

If Sam contributed to the HSA outside payroll instead, the contribution could still be deducted on the tax return, but Social Security and Medicare on it would not be recovered.

How federal withholding was calculated

  1. Without: $3,000 × 26 = $78,000; minus $8,600 = $69,400; $5,800 + 22% × ($69,400 − $57,900) = $8,330; ÷ 26 = $320.38.
  2. With: $2,750 × 26 = $71,500; minus $8,600 = $62,900; $5,800 + 22% × ($62,900 − $57,900) = $6,900; ÷ 26 = $265.38.

Common mistakes

  • Forgetting that employer HSA contributions count toward the annual HSA limit.
  • Electing a general-purpose health FSA alongside an HSA; only a limited-purpose FSA is compatible with HSA eligibility.
  • Expecting FSA money to roll over without checking whether the plan offers a carryover or grace period.

How these figures were calculated

2026 HSA limits from Rev. Proc. 2025-19; 2026 health FSA limit and carryover from Rev. Proc. 2025-32. Cafeteria-plan contributions excluded from FIT and FICA wages (IRS Publication 15-B, Publication 969). Withholding per Publication 15-T (2026). Verified with the PayStubPro paycheck calculator.

Sources

General information for legitimate payroll records, not tax or legal advice. PayStubPro prepares documents from the figures you enter; it does not verify income or employment.